Case file SDA-2023-ISLAMIC
Stamp duty on Islamic finance instruments aligned with conventional instruments
Highest rung reached: Verified lawLaw: read in a statutory textAdministration · Investment and industry
1 point pending verification
- The FY2023/24 budget speech and its forecast; URA prints yields by tax head only for this year.
Law
- Principal Act
- Stamp Duty Act (Cap 339), enacted as Act 13 of 2014
- Amending Act
- Stamp Duty (Amendment) Act 2023 (Act 21 of 2023) (verified)
- Provision, revised numbering (2023 revision)
- pending verification
- Provision, numbering before the revision
- s. 63A and Sch. 2
- Principal Act dates
- assent 2014-10-19; gazette 2014-10-24; commencement 2014-07-01; Uganda Gazette 61
- Amending Act in force from
- 25 August 2023 (assented 17 August 2023; gazetted 25 August 2023)
- Tax heads and taxpayers affected
- Stamp duty. Islamic banks, takaful insurers and the special purpose vehicles that issue Islamic bonds.
- Status
- Legal: pending verification. Implementation: pending verification.
The wording in force
as at 2023-08-25
63A. Re-characterisation of instruments under Islamic financial business (1) For purposes of determining whether an instrument is chargeable with duty under this Act, the Commissioner may re-characterise an instrument under Islamic financial business not provided for under this Act to the equivalent instrument under conventional financial services for purposes of reflecting the equivalent economic substance, rather than the form. Verified law: Wording or a date read in a statutory text, with the version and page named.[ACT-SDA-2023-21, PDF page 5, s. 3]
Redline pending verification
Reason
Stated objective pending verification
Revenue
Amendment-level revenue contribution not reliably quantified.
- Rung 1
Observed change
Observed: A value or event as an official source records it, copied without calculation.Missing. The story page draws no collections series for this tax head, so no before and after is shown.
- Rung 2
Official forecast
Official forecast: What MoFPED or URA said a measure would raise, or why it was made, before the year began.Missing. No official forecast for this measure was found in the budget documents or URA reports read. The budget speech and the Finance Bill memorandum for the year would settle it (MoFPED).
- Rung 3
Reported yield
Reported yield: What URA attributes to a measure after the year. An official attribution, not a causal estimate.Missing. URA's annual revenue reports read for the register attribute no yield to this measure. URA's measure-level policy tables, where they exist, would settle it (URA Research and Planning).
- Rung 4
Static or modelled estimate
Modelled estimate: A mechanical or model calculation, with every assumption shown.Missing. No estimate made. A static estimate needs the taxable base before the change (volumes or values by product), which the register does not hold.
- Rung 5
Causal estimate
Causal estimate: An effect identified by a stated research design against a comparison group.Missing. No study with a defensible identification strategy was found for this amendment.
- Rung 6
Wider impact
Interpretation: A reading of the evidence, by a named source or by this register.Missing. No source read for the register describes effects on prices, compliance cost, investment or equity.
What is known, what is uncertain, and what would settle it
- Known: only the collections of the tax heads affected.
- Uncertain: observed change, official forecast, reported yield, static or modelled estimate, causal estimate, wider impact; and 1 open point below.
Pathway
From the amendment to its wider consequences. Select a link to read what supports it. No money is drawn along the chain, because no flow along it is measured.
Verified: A source read for the register documents this link.
The provision is read in the ULII consolidated text.
- amendment: verified. The provision is read in the ULII consolidated text.
- mechanism: verified. A change in how tax is assessed or enforced, not in what is owed.
- implementation: no evidence. No source read dates its implementation.
- response: no evidence. No source read describes how taxpayers responded.
- outcome: no evidence. No reported yield or estimate.
- wider: no evidence. No source read measures wider effects. No evidence found is not evidence of no effect.
Consequences
Graded against ten criteria. No composite score: a reform that raises money can still be regressive or costly to comply with, and one that loses revenue can serve a legitimate aim. Revenue effectiveness is graded by a stated rule; the rest only where a source speaks to them.
What worked
No criterion graded effective on the evidence read.
What did not
No criterion graded ineffective or counterproductive on the evidence read.
Open or not evaluated
Revenue effectiveness
The measure was not meant to raise revenue, or its direction is unknown.(graded by rule)
Not evaluated
Legal clarity and certainty
No source read for the register speaks to this criterion.
Not evaluated
Administrative feasibility
No source read for the register speaks to this criterion.
Not evaluated
Compliance cost
No source read for the register speaks to this criterion.
Not evaluated
Efficiency
No source read for the register speaks to this criterion.
Not evaluated
Investment and competitiveness
No source read for the register speaks to this criterion.
Not evaluated
Vertical and horizontal equity
No source read for the register speaks to this criterion.
Not evaluated
Distributional effect
No source read for the register speaks to this criterion.
Not evaluated
Implementation quality
No source read for the register speaks to this criterion.
Not evaluated
Unintended consequences
No source read for the register speaks to this criterion.
Not evaluated
Afterlife
No Tax Appeals Tribunal or court decision on this provision is on record yet. That is not evidence that none exists.
Pending verification
- The FY2023/24 budget speech and its forecast; URA prints yields by tax head only for this year.
Sources
ACT-SDA-2023-21
Stamp Duty (Amendment) Act, 2023 (Act 21 of 2023)
Parliament of Uganda; Uganda Printing and Publishing Corporation. 2023-08-25. Covers In force from its commencement.
Desktop/Tax legislation Amendment Acts/Income Tax (Amendment) Act, 2023.pdf
Status: verified. Pages confirmed for this record in the source audit: 5 (PDF).
Acts Supplement No. 11 to the Uganda Gazette No. 56, Volume CXVI, dated 25 August 2023, at PDF pages 1 to 9 of the file named Income Tax (Amendment) Act 2023.